One of the sad parts about being in Eastern Christian is the fact that we are deeply aware of the separation between East and West. This last Saturday I walked into an Orthodox church, looked around the icons, the candle stands. I realized, that for me, the separation between East and West is something that I deal with on a daily basis.
One of these images is from an Orthodox Church, One is from an Eastern Catholic Church.

To all intensive purposes I was home. the liturgy was the same the only thing different was it was more ancient I.E.the English was in the more familiar. Replacing the more formal you and your was thees and thys. Yet there was a distinct separation, For I am not in union with them.
I get the sense that if an Orthodox Christian were to walk into my parish they would feel the same. My parish has done away with a lot of the latinizations that have creeped in over the years. So that when you walk in it looks and feels like an Orthodox church. But the distinct issue remains the same. We are separated and we know it.
Back to the Eastern Orthodox parish, there I was chanting the prayers knowing them by heart and realizing that my brothers and sisters and I have a wall between us that is invisible. So heavy was the realization of this separation of centuries that it was painful. The sad fact is that both Orthodox and Eastern Catholic know this at some level.
Roman Catholics cannot really understand what is going on here. Many of them don’t even know that the Eastern rite exists. Even the Roman Catholic bishops don’t truly comprehend us or understand us. even within Eastern Catholicism there are many who don’t understand who we are or what we are. It is as if the Eastern rites have a bout of amnesia and they have forgotten who they are. Unfortunately the bishops of the Eastern rite have also fallen into this problem that they do not know who they are or what they are.
For an Eastern Catholic, who is deeply involved in their faith, who studies the issues from both sides, who has friends who are Orthodox, realizes the deep pain and misery that truly encompasses the eastern part of the body of Christ. There is deep pain. It is like a poor man finding out that he has been left a large fortune, but the fortune is being denied to him, through some type of legal maneuver by a crafty legal team. The only way that the Eastern rites will survive, will be to completely reincorporate themselves into true Orthodox theology, Orthodox thinking, and Orthodox liturgy. Until such time they will remain as stagnant museums which are on the way to closing. The Eastern rites are steeped in ethnicity, and it’s this ethnicity that is going to be their downfall. Half measures do not work, when those who find Orthodoxy in union with Rome scratch the surface they find a thin veneer of orthodoxy. And wanting to steep themselves more deeply they find they cannot get this within the Eastern rites so they have to go to the Orthodox. Even the Vatican has told the Eastern rite Catholics that where we are lacking in our spirituality we must go back to the Orthodox. Even the Vatican realizes that on some level that due to miscalculated meddling that the Eastern rite Catholics have been robbed of many of their authentic traditions. In the end, the ultimate goal, should be the total reincorporation of the Eastern Catholic Churches with those Orthodox Churches that they once were part of. The separation from our roots, and our brothers, is killing us. It is like taking a plant out of the soil that it was created to live in and transferring it to a different environment. Withering death follows.
I say these words not to hurt but to bring them to light. If we are truly to understand the issue of Eastern Catholicism then we must understand the roots. We must understand why we exist and we must actually come to terms on how and why we came into being. In my own church if we are really honest we must understand that union came about because of a more political issue rather than theological. If we’re to be true to ourselves then we must understand this and acknowledge it.
Again, nowhere in Christianity, are the wounds of separation so distinct, so raw, and so tender. My prayer is that the Christian West, and the Orthodox East can someday come together and be one again. The healing of this tragic wound is sorely needed. However reunification isn’t going to be easy. There are issues on both sides that need to be deeply looked at. Pope Paul the sixth, Pope John Paul II, and Pope Benedict the 16th, have all talked about a re-image of the papacy, let us hope that this means that the West is serious about looking into the hard issues of reunification between the churches. I also truly hope that the Eastern churches are serious about looking into the hard issues. The fracture of the body of Christ is diabolical. Much prayer, fasting, and listening are needed on both sides.
I guess why I’m writing this is that I have seen the wound and terrible scars and it makes me truly sad.